CNN
—
Touchdown on Netflix because the trial of Alex Murdaugh continues, “Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal” will definitely profit from its timeliness, however this three-part manufacturing isn’t as compelling as its material. Relying virtually solely on these concerned to inform the story, the undertaking has a slapdash really feel from starting to finish, and finds the youthful contingent, particularly, to be poor narrators of what transpired.
Certainly, if ever a true-crime docuseries would have benefited from utilizing a narrator, it’s this one; as a substitute, the producers let the group of buddies who have been swept up within the tragic boat accident that claimed the lifetime of 19-year-old Mallory Seaside drone on, augmenting their accounts with blurry reenactments that appear like one thing out of an affordable horror film.
Though the title “Murdaugh Murders” ostensibly references the killing of Paul Murdaugh and his mom, Maggie, which resulted in his father and her husband, Alex, being placed on trial, that’s one thing of an afterthought in the way in which the episodes are constructed. The main target of the primary two elements, reasonably, facilities on the boat crash.
Those that have been on board converse of Paul, who usually drank excessively, driving the boat, and the Murdaugh household – because of patriarch Alex, a well-connected South Carolina lawyer – allegedly utilizing its wealth and affect over the authorities to guard him.
As the small print step by step come out, there are different inconsistencies and allegations about events the place the Murdaughs escaped scrutiny within the face of suspicious occasions, together with the demise of a housekeeper and nanny, Gloria Satterfield, who, they claimed, was severely injured when the household canine induced her to fall down a flight of stairs.
“Murdaugh Murders” options interviews with a number of key figures, together with Paul’s girlfriend, Morgan Doughty; Mallory Seaside’s buddies Miley Altman and Connor Prepare dinner; and Mallory’s boyfriend, Anthony Prepare dinner. But essentially the most illuminating data comes from an lawyer for Seaside’s household, Mark Tinsley, who lays out proof of incidents when the Murdaughs allegedly obtained particular therapy from the authorities, which fits past Paul avoiding penalties for the deadly boating accident.
Generally it’s merely sufficient to be in the correct place on the proper time, and primarily based on the success Netflix has loved with the true-crime style, usually constructed round household tragedies, having a docuseries able to go as Alex Murdaugh’s trial instructions headlines falls squarely into that basket even whether it is, by its very nature, chasing a shifting goal. What “Murdaugh Murders” doesn’t do, in the end, is make a lot of a case for watching it.
“Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal” premieres February 22 on Netflix.
